Cigar Rating Submission Form:
General Information:
Reviewer's Name:
e-Mail Address:
Cigar Brand:
Size Name:
Length/Ring Size:
" x
64ths
Country of Origin:
Price per Cigar:
Did you like the cigar?
Yes, GREAT!
Yes
OK
No
Terrible!
Appearance and Presentation:
Wrapper Color:
(EMS,Natural,Colorado,Madoro...)
Wrapper Surface:
(Oily, Dry, Papery, Silky...)
Veiny or Smooth?
Very Veiny
Veiny
Slightly Veiny
Fairly Smooth
Smooth
Overall Wrapper Rating?
Beautiful
Appealing
OK
Nothing Special
Bad
Terrible
Construction:
HARD
MED
SOFT
MUSHY
Overall Packaging:
Very Appealing
Nice
OK
Plain
Bad
Cap Construction:
GOOD
BAD
Ease of Cutting:
GOOD
ACCEPTABLE
BAD
Lighting and Burning:
Initial Burning:
Perfectly Cocentric
Fairly Even
OK
Poor
Terrible
Burning at Halfway:
Perfectly Cocentric
Fairly Even
OK
Poor
Terrible
Burning at 75%:
Perfectly Cocentric
Fairly Even
OK
Poor
Terrible
When burning in ash tray:
Light, Even Smoke
Smokey
Almost goes out!
Burn Rate:
Too Fast
OK
Perfect
Too Slow
Had to keep puffing!
Required Relighting?
YES
NO
Ash Color:
White
Lt.Grey
Grey
Dk.Grey
Brown
Black
Ash Hardness:
Solid
Cracky
Crumbly
Flakey
Construction:
Initial Draw:
Plugged
Very Tight
Tight
Good
Perfect
Loose
Very Loose
Draw at 25%:
Plugged
Very Tight
Tight
Good
Perfect
Loose
Very Loose
Draw at 50%:
Plugged
Very Tight
Tight
Good
Perfect
Loose
Very Loose
Draw at 75%:
Plugged
Very Tight
Tight
Good
Perfect
Loose
Very Loose
Wrapper Stays Intact?
Yes
No
TASTE:
Opinion of Taste:
Best Taste Ever!
Great
Very Good
Good
OK
NOT GOOD
BAD
TERRIBLE
Body:
Very Mild
Mild
Medium
Med-Full
Full
Heavy
Quality:
Bitter
Harsh
Slightly Harsh
Smooth
Very Smooth
Don't Know
Flavors Detected:
Sweet
Salty
Bland
Vegital
Spicy
Peppery
Cocoa
Coffee
Leathery
OTHER:
Aged?
Yes
Aged for:
Aroma:
Very Good
Good
Bad
Overpowering
Finish:
Comments:
- or -